Legally Enforceable?
Yes, a non-compete is legal in New York if it follows a three-pronged test.[1]
- Protectable interest. Is no greater than is required for the protection of the legitimate protectable interest of the employer;
- Undue hardship. Does not impose an undue hardship on the employee; and
- Public policy. Is not injurious to the public.
New York limits an employer on the justification for a protectable interest to:[2]
- Protection of trade secrets;
- Protection of confidential customer information;
- Protection of an employer’s client base; and
- Protection against irreparable harm where an employee’s services are unique or extraordinary.
In addition, a non-compete must include “adequate consideration,” which may include:[3][4]
- Cash payment;
- Full-time or continued employment (if employment is for a “substantial” amount of time after the agreement was signed);
- Promotion;
- Added benefits;
- Ownership; or
- Any other monetary consideration.
An attorney is not allowed to enter into a non-compete or any agreement that prohibits them from practicing law in the State.[5]
Maximum Term
- 2 years has been deemed to be a reasonable time period by the Supreme Court for employment purposes.[3]
- 5 years have been deemed to be a reasonable time period by District Court for selling a business.[6]
Although, the duration and geographical area are both considered when deciding if a non-compete is reasonable.
Blue Penciling
New York courts have amended broad and unreasonable non-compete covenants to make them reasonable only if the “unenforceable portion is not an essential part of the agreed exchange.”[2]
The court amended to make the non-compete more narrow for the scope of work limitations related to dentistry.[7]
The agreement did not include a geographical area, therefore the non-compete was deemed unenforceable.[8]
“Non-Compete Agreement” Definition
A non-competition agreement (“non-compete”) prohibits an employee from working for a competitor or opening a competing business, typically for a certain period of time after an employee leaves a job. A non-compete may be one section of an employment contract or a standalone contract that an employee signs before or after employment begins.[9]
Sources
- BDO Seidman v. Hirshberg (1999)
- Silipos, Inc. Bickel (2006)
- Zellner v. Conrad (1992)
- Maltby v. Harlow Meyer Savage (1995)
- Rule 5.6 (Restrictions on Right to Practice)
- Intertek Testing Services, N.A., Inc. v. Pennisi (2020)
- Karpinski v. Ingrasci (1971)
- AM Medica Communications Group v. Kilgallen (2003)
- NY Attorney General (Non-Compete Agreements in New York State)